Monday, July 2, 2012

Comparison of Netezza, Teradata, Exadata


Criteria
Appliance Name
Netezza
Teradata
Exadata
Architecture Highlights

Scalability, Parallelism
Scalability, Parallelism
Scalability, Parallelism
Parallelism Concept

AMPP1
SMP2 & MPP3
MPP
Hardware

HP
NCR
HP Proliant DL180 G5
Network Interface

Gigabit Ethernet (1 GB/sec)
BYNET
InfiniBand (16 GB/sec)
Software
OS
Linux (Redhat)
Windows, Linux and NCR UNIX
Oracle Enterprise Linux
RDBMS
Porstgre based
Teradata Database
Oracle
Query Processing
Managed by
Hardware
Virtual Process (Software)
RDBMS Software
Key Processing Unit
FPGA4
VPROC5 (AMP6)
as Oracle
Executed
completely in Disk
virtually in disk
Both in Disk and Database server
Scalability

Linear Scalable
Linear Scalable
Linear Scalable
Failover

Built-in
Built-in
Built-in
Availability

Built-in
Built-in
Built-in
Usage of Index

Not used
Extensively used
moderately used
ETL7

ELT8
ETL
ETL
Migration Effort

High as new architecture
High as new architecture
Comparatively less effort
Administration

Less
Less
More than Netezza and Teradata



  1- Asymmetric Massively Parallel Processing
  2- Symmetric Multi Processing
  3- Massively Parallel Processing
  4- Field Programmable Gate Array 
  5- Virtual Processor
  6- Acess Module Processor
  7- Extract, Transformation, Load
  8- Extract, Load, Transformation



4 comments:

  1. Many people are quick to offer subjective opinions simply because they may be familiar with one system, but not with other one. In any discussion of these machines, it is essential to leave your personal preference and experience behind you, and discuss the pros and cons of each objectively. We as XDuce are organizing a workshop for Exadata Database Machine Administration. Connect here for more details and registrations: Exadata Machine Training

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for this comprehensive comparison! One great way to determine the most effective Data Warehousing solution for your company is by reading user feedback. You can find real user reviews for Teradata, Netezza, Exadata and all the other major Data Warehousing tools on IT Central Station: https://goo.gl/uJnUkc

    The IT Central Station user community ranked Exadata the #1 tool in Data Warehousing. This user writes, "What makes Exadata different than competitors is that it is not designed only for a specific application (as in SAP HANA), and is not only for a certain type of workload (as in Teradata)." You can read the rest of his review, as well as explore what others have to say about Oracle Exadata, here: https://goo.gl/5VTVYr

    ReplyDelete
  3. This is a very good content I read this blog, please share more content on MSBI Online Course Bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  4. This blog very easily understandable. Thanks for sharing such an informative post with us. This is a nice post in an interesting line of content.
    Exadata Training in Bangalore

    ReplyDelete